I couldn't decide, but am leaning towards Chris Weitz's vision 7 out of 11 times. Love Victoria's flaming hair in New Moon, but kind of think Alice's quirky clothes and spiky hair from Twilight is more true to the books. And Carlisle? Well, I think his make-up in New Moon is definitely better (bye-bye red lipstick), but what up with his hair?
What do you think? Weigh in here.